It usually starts the same way: polished dashboards, tempting price tags, and confident assurances of high-quality panels - only to discover later that the data doesn’t stand up when it matters most.

The truth is: technology and prices can look impressive, but if the underlying data is weak, everything built on top of it collapses.

This data quality checklist is your reality check. Use it to cut through the sales talk and make sure you’re protecting the one non-negotiable: data quality.

Download the checklist as a PDF

The key questions you should be asking:

1. Representation: does the sample reflect the real world?

Too many providers boast panel size without proving who’s behind the numbers.

Ask your provider:

  • Do you own your panel?

If not, be wary. Brokered traffic = minimal provenance and limited control.

If they do then:

  • How do you recruit?
  • How do you verify?

If they can’t prove ownership and representativeness, assume misrepresentation is built in.

2. Integrity: are the respondents real, unique, and fraud-free?

VPN masking, duplicate accounts, bots, even AI-generated qual answers. Fraud is everywhere.

Ask your provider:

  • What multi-layer fraud controls run before, during, and after each survey?
  • How do you detect VPNs, device duplication, and synthetic answers?
  • What's your verified fraud rate?

If you get a vague answer, your results are questionable.

3. Accuracy: are the answers thoughtful and valid?

Long confusing surveys with poor safeguards create rushed and implausible answers.

Ask your provider:

  • How do you design for clarity?
  • What in-survey accuracy checks do you run?
  • How do you catch contradictory, random, or disengaged answers in real time?

No cleaning step can fix bad questions or inattentive respondents.

4. Connected: is each answer tied back to a real person over time?

One off surveys are just snapshots. Without persistent profiles, you can't spot contradictions or track real change.

Ask your provider:

  • Can today's answers be linked to the same person's past responses, behaviors, or attributes?
  • Do you maintain longitudinal identity of just anonymous traffic?

If not then you are missing vital context that severely reduced the effectiveness of your paid for research.

5. Member experience: are participants treated as people or churned through

Are participants treated as people - or churned through?

Disengaged, tired panelists rush. They fake answers. They leave.

Ask your provider:

  • How do you reduce screen-outs and survey fatigue?
  • How do you keep panelists engaged, informed, and valued?
  • How do you measure and maintain long-term panel health?

Good experience = good data

Bad experience = bad data in, bad data out

6. Benchmarking & transparency: can they prove their claims?

Will they share their fraud rate or show how they stack up against other providers?

Ask your provider:

  • Do they run benchmarking studies?
  • Are they willing to share actual evidence and not just big numbers?

If there's no transparency, there's a reason.

How YouGov does it differently

While others chase volume and cost savings, we’ve spent decades building quality into every stage of the process.

  • Proprietary safeguards: our Response Quality Score (RQS) and Awareness Cross-Entropy (ACE) catch bad data no one else can.
  • Connected data architecture: every answer is tied to a long-term profile, giving you confidence in the depth and accuracy.
  • Global, verified panel: millions of members across 55 markets, continuously benchmarked against census standards.
  • Proven track record: trusted for election forecasts, brand tracking, and the high-stakes decisions where data can’t fail.
Read the full report to find out how we deliver accuracy.Find out more
Subscribe to your sector newsletter