The latest episode of Reality checks with Brian Reitz features Mary Meehan, CEO & Co-founder at Metametrix & Co-founder at Panoramix Global, covering why Americans make ethical decisions, what causes them to act against their values, and how personal values have changed over time.

What factors matter most when Americans find themselves wrestling with a difficult decision, and how much do personal values impact the outcome?

Mary Meehan, CEO & Co-founder at Metametrx & Co-founder at Panoramix Global, collaborated with YouGov on a five-question survey of 1,000 Americans to find out.

“[I’m] working on a book right now with two co-authors,” said Meehan. “We’ve been able to show how our priorities, those values that guide us, influence what we choose, and in turn, shapes what we value.”

Want to run your own survey? Reach nationally representative or targeted audiences.Explore options

The article below provides further analysis to support the interview, answering:

  • What matters most when making difficult decisions?
  • How often do Americans compromise on their values?
  • What causes Americans to compromise on their values?
  • Which value blockers are most likely to result in actual compromises?
  • How do Americans weigh decisions?
  • How have personal values changed over time?

What’s important for decisions?

Four in ten Americans (41%) say doing what they believe is right is usually most important to them when making a difficult decision, a clear leader ahead of protecting themselves or their family (23%) and achieving the best practical outcome (20%).

Men and women are equally likely to prioritize protecting themselves or their family (22% and 24%), but men are more likely than women to say the best practical outcome matters most (24% vs. 16%).

Meanwhile, women are slightly more likely than men to say they put doing what’s right first (42% vs. 39%).

How often do Americans have to compromise their values?


In the past year, about one in six Americans (17%) regularly made decisions that went against something they personally believe is important (combining “very often” and “somewhat often”), while 44% say they have done so not very often and 29% say never.

Older Americans are less likely to say they feel like they have to compromise their values, as the frequency of acting against one’s values declines steadily with age: 28% of Gen Z say they have done so very or somewhat often, compared with 21% of Millennials, 16% of Gen X, and 7% of Baby Boomers.

Gen Z (29%) are more than four times as likely as Baby Boomers (7%) to say they regularly decided against their values in the last year.

What causes Americans to compromise on their values?

Money or financial pressures are the most-cited obstacle to acting according to one’s personal values, named by one in four Americans (25%).

Pressure or expectations from others and responsibilities to other people follow, each at 12%, ahead of conflicting personal priorities (9%) and a lack of time or energy (8%).

Notably, no single reason eclipsed the percentage of respondents who said nothing makes it particularly difficult to live their values (26%).

“Values don’t operate in a vacuum, and there’s all these other mitigating factors that make a choice more difficult,” said Meehan.

Which value blockers are most likely to result in actual compromises?

While money is the most-mentioned barrier to living one’s values, Americans who point to financial pressures are no more likely than average to say they have often acted against their beliefs in the past year (15% vs. 17% overall).

Instead, those who point to other people show bigger differences: 29% of those who say responsibilities to others are their main obstacle, and 25% of those who cite pressure or expectations from others, say they have made decisions contradicting their values very or somewhat often.

In other words, while Americans may feel that finances prevent them from acting on their values, it’s more likely due to other people in their lives, a contradiction Meehan identified as the do-say gap.

How do Americans weigh decisions with positive and negative tradeoffs?

When a decision benefits many but harms a few, Americans are most likely to say it depends too much on the circumstances to judge (38%).

Among those with firmer views, more say such a decision should be avoided if it seriously harms even a small group (22%) than say it is justified when the overall benefits outweigh the harms (15%) or only when those affected receive protection or compensation (15%).

Adults under 35 are roughly twice as likely as older Americans to say compensation or protection is required (23% vs. 13% of those 35-54 and 11% of those 55+), while the share saying it depends on the circumstances rises with age, from 29% of those 18-34 to 36% of those 35-54 and 44% of those 55+.

Do Americans think their values have changed over time?

Roughly half of Americans (49%) say their values or their order of importance shifted over the past decade, though most of that is reprioritizing rather than fundamental change (38% vs. 11%), while 42% say their values have stayed mostly the same.

Stability in values rises with age: 56% of Baby Boomers say their values and priorities have stayed the same, compared with 44% of Gen X, 35% of Millennials, and 24% of Gen Z.

Gen Z is about five times more likely than Baby Boomers to say their fundamental values have changed significantly (20% vs. 4%).

Need data to help make a difficult business decision?Run a survey

Disclosure: AI contributed to the writing of this article.

Subscribe to the YouGov newsletter